| 1 | Sam Lewis Winner62% picked right · Tiebreaker 142 (off by 7) 62% picked right · Tiebreaker 142 (off by 7)13953 | 139 | Connecticut | 171342 |
| 2 | 62% picked right · Tiebreaker 147 (off by 12) 13062 | 130 | Connecticut | 221022 |
| 3 | 67% picked right · Tiebreaker 135 (off by 0) 11973 | 119 | Connecticut | 231241 |
| 4 | 63% picked right · Tiebreaker 149 (off by 14) 11973 | 119 | Connecticut | 211151 |
| 5 | 63% picked right · Tiebreaker 155 (off by 20) 11775 | 117 | Connecticut | 231122 |
| 6 | Matt Lewis63% picked right · Tiebreaker 148 (off by 13) 63% picked right · Tiebreaker 148 (off by 13)11676 | 116 | Connecticut | 241022 |
| 7 | 65% picked right · Tiebreaker 136 (off by 1) 11577 | 115 | Connecticut | 231231 |
| 8 | 59% picked right · Tiebreaker 141 (off by 6) 11478 | 114 | Connecticut | 181241 |
| 9 | 62% picked right · Tiebreaker 122 (off by 13) 11478 | 114 | Connecticut | 201331 |
| 10 | 65% picked right · Tiebreaker 136 (off by 1) 11379 | 113 | Connecticut | 251031 |
| 11 | 54% picked right · Tiebreaker 137 (off by 2) 10983 | 109 | Connecticut | 19922 |
| 12 | 59% picked right · Tiebreaker 138 (off by 3) 10785 | 107 | Connecticut | 211121 |
| 13 | 59% picked right · Tiebreaker 176 (off by 41) 10785 | 107 | Connecticut | 211121 |
| 14 | 54% picked right · Tiebreaker 150 (off by 15) 10488 | 104 | Connecticut | 181121 |
| 15 | 56% picked right · Tiebreaker 172 (off by 37) 10488 | 104 | Connecticut | 201021 |
| 16 | 67% picked right · Tiebreaker 149 (off by 14) 10290 | 102 | Houston | 221243 |
| 17 | 52% picked right · Tiebreaker 110 (off by 25) 10092 | 100 | Connecticut | 20821 |
| 18 | 59% picked right · Tiebreaker 154 (off by 19) 9894 | 98 | Purdue | 201122 |
| 19 | 68% picked right · Tiebreaker 159 (off by 24) 9696 | 96 | Purdue | 241242 |
| 20 | 65% picked right · Tiebreaker 133 (off by 2) 9498 | 94 | Purdue | 221242 |
| 21 | 70% picked right · Tiebreaker 145 (off by 10) 92100 | 92 | Marquette | 241441 |
| 22 | 65% picked right · Tiebreaker 170 (off by 35) 92100 | 92 | Purdue | 201451 |
| 23 | 60% picked right · Tiebreaker 135 (off by 0) 88104 | 88 | Purdue | 201232 |
| 24 | 59% picked right · Tiebreaker 136 (off by 1) 88104 | 88 | Houston | 201042 |
| 25 | 63% picked right · Tiebreaker 150 (off by 15) 88104 | 88 | Iowa St | 201441 |
| 26 | 67% picked right · Tiebreaker 143 (off by 8) 86106 | 86 | Iowa St | 241331 |
| 27 | Dan Bown62% picked right · Tiebreaker 112 (off by 23) 62% picked right · Tiebreaker 112 (off by 23)85107 | 85 | Iowa St | 211241 |
| 28 | 57% picked right · Tiebreaker 146 (off by 11) 73119 | 73 | Iowa St | 23921 |
| 29 | 56% picked right · Tiebreaker 150 (off by 15) 73119 | 73 | Purdue | 211021 |
| 30 | 49% picked right · Tiebreaker 167 (off by 32) 73119 | 73 | Duke | 17841 |
| 31 | Elliot Fair54% picked right · Tiebreaker 159 (off by 24) 54% picked right · Tiebreaker 159 (off by 24)70122 | 70 | Kentucky | 201111 |
| 32 | 60% picked right · Tiebreaker 131 (off by 4) 69123 | 69 | Iowa St | 231122 |
| 33 | 60% picked right · Tiebreaker 150 (off by 15) 69123 | 69 | North Carolina | 211241 |
| 34 | Matt Stiles63% picked right · Tiebreaker 159 (off by 24) 63% picked right · Tiebreaker 159 (off by 24)67125 | 67 | Arizona | 251131 |
| 35 | 62% picked right · Tiebreaker 135 (off by 0) 65127 | 65 | Tennessee | 211440 |
| 36 | 59% picked right · Tiebreaker 128 (off by 7) 65127 | 65 | Houston | 211231 |
| 37 | 60% picked right · Tiebreaker 160 (off by 25) 61131 | 61 | Iowa St | 211430 |
| 38 | 56% picked right · Tiebreaker 160 (off by 25) 60132 | 60 | Houston | 22931 |
| 39 | 56% picked right · Tiebreaker 134 (off by 1) 58134 | 58 | Houston | 221021 |
| 40 | 59% picked right · Tiebreaker 144 (off by 9) 58134 | 58 | Iowa St | 221230 |
| 41 | 54% picked right · Tiebreaker 165 (off by 30) 58134 | 58 | Arizona | 201121 |
| 42 | 59% picked right · Tiebreaker 99 (off by 36) 58134 | 58 | Iowa St | 221230 |
| 43 | 54% picked right · Tiebreaker 128 (off by 7) 56136 | 56 | Houston | 201211 |
| 44 | 54% picked right · Tiebreaker 91 (off by 44) 56136 | 56 | North Carolina | 22921 |
| 45 | 59% picked right · Tiebreaker 137 (off by 2) 55137 | 55 | Iowa St | 231220 |
| 46 | 54% picked right · Tiebreaker 172 (off by 37) 54138 | 54 | Iowa St | 201130 |
| 47 | 57% picked right · Tiebreaker 137 (off by 2) 53139 | 53 | Iowa St | 231120 |
| 48 | Tony Riewer56% picked right · Tiebreaker 128 (off by 7) 56% picked right · Tiebreaker 128 (off by 7)53139 | 53 | Iowa St | 211220 |
| 49 | 51% picked right · Tiebreaker 155 (off by 20) 51141 | 51 | Arizona | 191030 |
| 50 | Dustin Good52% picked right · Tiebreaker 138 (off by 3) 52% picked right · Tiebreaker 138 (off by 3)47145 | 47 | Iowa St | 211110 |
| 51 | 48% picked right · Tiebreaker 150 (off by 15) 47145 | 47 | Tennessee | 19830 |
| 52 | 51% picked right · Tiebreaker 121 (off by 14) 46146 | 46 | Iowa St | 201110 |
| 53 | Ryan Skow51% picked right · Tiebreaker 100 (off by 35) 51% picked right · Tiebreaker 100 (off by 35)46146 | 46 | Iowa St | 201110 |
| 54 | Faye Walter41% picked right · Tiebreaker 148 (off by 13) 41% picked right · Tiebreaker 148 (off by 13)43149 | 43 | Iowa St | 19421 |
| 55 | Greg Huyser46% picked right · Tiebreaker 143 (off by 8) 46% picked right · Tiebreaker 143 (off by 8)39153 | 39 | Iowa St | 191000 |
| 56 | 38% picked right · Tiebreaker 137 (off by 2) 33159 | 33 | Iowa St | 17610 |
| 57 | Fern Walter37% picked right · Tiebreaker 147 (off by 12) 37% picked right · Tiebreaker 147 (off by 12)30162 | 30 | Iowa St | 18410 |